@thevantagepoint
Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Board: Effective Governance

by Vantage Point | Apr 17, 2018

Serving on a board should be fun and engaging. At Vantage Point we’re passionate advocates for governance that goes beyond oversight. With a focus on impact, there are some great practices organizations can use to support meaningful governance In our work we often come across organizations that have developed or adopted unique governance practices that are aligned with their values.

Many of these practices also foster a board dynamic that is engaging, fun and grounded in community impact. Two great examples are Exchange Innercity and HUB Cycling.

Here are some of the practices these two organizations have in place to make their governance awesome!

1. Make information accessible before the meeting

Exchange Innercity is a community economic development organization comprised of individuals and community groups in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. The organization prides itself on taking direction and leadership from the membership as a whole. All members are invited to attend committee meetings. However, with a diverse and broad membership, ensuring meeting attendees have sufficient information to participate effectively is no small task. In order to achieve this, the coordinator makes herself available for 3 hours per month (1.5 hours on the second and third Wednesday of every month) at a local community centre where she provides printed meeting packages. Participants who don’t have access to a computer or email can get the information they need prior to any of the meetings.

HUB Cycling, uses a consent agenda. This tool requires a reading package to be sent out at least one week in advance, so that key information items are not reviewed at the meeting itself. Board members arrive prepared to delve into discussion.

2. Define “consensus decision-making” and dedicate time to “discursive” items

HUB Cycling has identified that board meetings are most effective when they allow for discussion and dialogue (instead of using meeting time to share information). To ensure this happens, the meeting agendas include a standing ‘discursive’ topic section, where rotating board members bring forward innovative, generative and diverse topics for dialogue at the board level. These items are for discussion only - decisions are not typically required - which opens up the meetings to generative reflection, discussion, and engaging new ideas at board meetings.

When it does come to making decisions, some groups use a ‘consensus-based’ decision making model. However, trouble arises when this is not defined; consensus means very different things to different people. To mitigate this challenge, Exchange Innercity proactively created a governing document that defines precisely how they can achieve a decision and the procedures to follow in order to empower members to raise and deal with conflicting viewpoints.

3. Mission first

For both organizations, keeping mission top of mind is a key feature of how they’ve structured governance practices. At the beginning of HUB board meetings a rotating board member will outline the mission and priorities of the organization, as they understand them. This grounds the subsequent discussions in what the board is there to achieve.

At Exchange Innercity, a key part of their mission is empowering individuals and organizations in the Downtown Eastside. They’ve given much thought to meeting processes as well as clear definitions to the roles of the staff, the executive committee, and committee members to ensure members have ample opportunities to contribute in different ways - which is a critical part of their mission.

How do your governance practices reflect the values of your organization, or the mission? Are there governance practices unique to your organization?

Related Posts

PayPal Webinar

From Overwhelmed to Action: Diversify Your Charity’s Revenue Mix with No-Cost Digital Giving Tools

Join Vantage Point and PayPal Giving Fund for this practical webinar to explore how giving is changing in Canada and what it means for your organization. Through current sector data, real-world examples, and practical strategies, you’ll discover no-cost digital giving tools and community-led fundraising approaches that can help diversify your revenue and create new opportunities for donor engagement.

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Let’s reimagine the way we think about not-for-profit governance

Let’s reimagine the way we think about not-for-profit governance

Board: Effective Governance

by Vantage Point | Apr 12, 2018

For those of us who work with not-for-profit sector organizations and their governing bodies, the same issues in not-for-profit governance seem to keep coming up year after year. That insight has caused a thoughtful sector leader to ask: “why are we doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results?”

We hear these types of stories all the time:

“My board blurs the lines between operations and governance.”

“The executive director expects the board to fundraise, that’s not what I signed up for!”

“Nobody told me we’d spend so much time looking at boring financial statements.”

“We elected a chartered accountant to the board, and now he’s refusing to act as Treasurer!”

“We’ve tried to recruit for diversity on our board, but we don’t know any qualified candidates from minority communities.”

Reimagining Governance

On March 12, Vantage Point partnered with Ignite NPS to start conversations on how we can shift our perspective and do governance differently. Executive directors, board members and consultants met with Linda Mollenhauer to explore how not-for-profit governance structures, processes and practices should and could be adapted to meet the challenges of today’s complex environment.

Linda is a cofounder and the Board Chair Ignite NPS, where she volunteers her time and expertise to support development and distribution of practical research, resources and tools designed for board members and staff of non-profit organizations across the sector. Her goal is to foster new ways of working and support leaders to adapt to the complex and competitive not-for-profit landscape.

The questions Linda posed on March 12 certainly ignited my thinking! Here are three of the many insights raised in the three-hour facilitated conversation:

1. Governance is a team sport. All too often, we think of governance as the board’s work, but in fact, it involves the collaboration of the chief executive, staff, and stakeholders in the community served by a not-for-profit organization.

2. Successful governance requires a shared understanding. How often do we stop and explore what we mean by “successful governance”? Some people hear that word and think “govern”, focusing on the fiduciary. Others think “vision” or “leadership”. It’s time to get on the same page, to achieve clarity through an explicit conversation that leads to a shared understanding of what we mean by “successful governance”.

3. Each of us has a role in finding a new model. If we always do what we’ve always done, we’ll always get what we’ve always got. Everyone working in the sector can shift our energy, from focusing on the challenges, to imagining how we could make it better.

Thanks, Vantage Point, for making space to encourage thought leadership and reimagine governance. It’s a conversation whose time has come!

Related Posts

PayPal Webinar

From Overwhelmed to Action: Diversify Your Charity’s Revenue Mix with No-Cost Digital Giving Tools

Join Vantage Point and PayPal Giving Fund for this practical webinar to explore how giving is changing in Canada and what it means for your organization. Through current sector data, real-world examples, and practical strategies, you’ll discover no-cost digital giving tools and community-led fundraising approaches that can help diversify your revenue and create new opportunities for donor engagement.

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Capacity Building: Enhancing Organizational Impact

Capacity Building: Enhancing Organizational Impact

Leadership: Develop Unlimited Talent

by Vantage Point | Apr 8, 2018

Not-for-profit organizations do incredibly important work – providing critical services that support and enrich our communities. Robust internal capacity and organizational competence is what supports their ability to achieve impact. At Vantage Point we are on a mission to improve not-for-profit capacity.

By building the capacity of your not-for-profit organization, you can strengthen the impact your programs have in your community and ensure long-term program sustainability. The importance of capacity building is a critical conversation for not-for-profits, funders, government, and the broader community. 

Defining Capacity

What exactly is capacity? It is impact. It is resilience. It is sustainability. Essentially, capacity building is an ongoing investment in the improved performance and sustainability of our people and organizations. What does an investment in capacity look like? It is a focus on and commitment to enhancing our internal governance, management, and operations. It can include professional development that improves staff leadership competencies, board governance training that enhances board effectiveness, or technology that improves customer and donor relations.

At Vantage Point we focus on four areas of not-for-profit capacity: management, governance, financial resources, and administrative systems1. In addition to strong program delivery, these are the organizational platforms that support and sustain an organization’s impact.

Why Does Capacity Building Matter?

Capacity building creates more effective and resilient not-for-profit organizations. Imagine the potential that your not-for-profit could achieve with fully equipped leaders, robust financial management systems, flexibility to adapt when challenges arise, and a collaborative work environment that allows for new ideas and generative thinking. When positioned this way, capacity building is sexy!

We see the impact of capacity building every day and our program evaluations show incredible results in areas such as leadership competencies, improved employee engagement, and increased fundraising. Capacity building takes time and investment, but the benefits far exceed the cost.

Our Next Steps

What does your internal capacity look like? We encourage you to start conversations with your colleagues and supporters about what increased capacity would mean for your organization. Let’s discover and unleash the potential in our teams and organizations and build stronger organizational competence.

At Vantage Point we are committed to capacity building and we will continue to engage leaders, funders, and the community on this important topic. We will highlight practical tools and share new insights along the way through our blog, resources, and new capacity resource page for not-for-profits.

Together, as not-for-profit leaders, funders, and community members let’s increase the capacity of not-for-profit organizations!

1 As identified in Nonprofit Lifecycles: Stage Based Wisdom for Nonprofit Capacity by Susan Kenny Stevens.

Related Posts

PayPal Webinar

From Overwhelmed to Action: Diversify Your Charity’s Revenue Mix with No-Cost Digital Giving Tools

Join Vantage Point and PayPal Giving Fund for this practical webinar to explore how giving is changing in Canada and what it means for your organization. Through current sector data, real-world examples, and practical strategies, you’ll discover no-cost digital giving tools and community-led fundraising approaches that can help diversify your revenue and create new opportunities for donor engagement.

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

Celebrating International Women’s Day: Five Lessons from Not-for-Profit Leaders

Celebrating International Women’s Day: Five Lessons from Not-for-Profit Leaders

Planning: Strategy & Workforce

by Vantage Point | Mar 6, 2018

As a leader within the not-for-profit sector for over 15 years now, I’ve had the opportunity to work with many incredible women. In celebration of International Women’s Day, I share here some of the key approaches that I have learned from these strong and smart individuals. I have found these practices to be essential in my own development as a leader – and as a woman.

1) When contemplating change, consider the importance of over-steering the boat to alter the course.

As a sailor, I’ve mulled on this analogy many times. When faced with a major change of course out on the water, I’ve seen what’s required of the skipper to set this new course. I’m naturally a more facilitative leader, who strives to gradually, and diplomatically, bring everyone along. In 2002 Vantage Point began a shift to re-orient our mission to build strong leaders and strong not-for-profit organizations. The Executive Director who was at the helm demonstrated the importance of over-steering, and not necessarily being able to bring everyone along.

2) In facing important decisions, ask yourself what each option makes possible, and for whom, while also acknowledging the worst that could happen in each case.

This practice, an aspect of Creating the Future’s Catalytic Thinking, has been essential to both my personal and professional decisions and I encourage you to try it out. I have also learned the benefit of framing “no” decisions as saying “yes” to another opportunity.

3) Start your day with a positive intention

It’s been a busy start to 2018 here at Vantage Point and I’m definitely aware of the “stretch” I’m experiencing. Starting each day with a positive intention has been tough. I’m sticking with it, however, as the simple practice of focusing on one positive thought or aspiration for the day truly brings out the best in me at home and work.

4) As leaders contributing to shaping and developing high performing cultures, get used to being a broken-record.

I’ve been constantly reminded of the importance of consistency by the Executive Directors I have had the privilege of working with here at Vantage Point. A strong culture at Vantage Point, with a commitment to abundance and people, has come through leadership that is comfortable persevering through challenges and making space for the many conversations required to assure board and staff are aligned (and re-aligned!) at every turn. I have seen the measurable outcomes of this leadership including demonstrated growth in mission impact.

5) Once in a while, ask yourself, “would I rather be somewhere else”?

I have committed both work and volunteer aspects of my life to the not-for-profit sector. To assure I’m still receiving energy from all that I put in, every once in a while, I intentionally ask this question. On occasion the answer is going to be “yes – I’d rather be doing…”. But for the most part, even when I’m feeling challenged, the answer is actually “this is exactly where I want to be”.

What meaningful practices have women in your life passed to you? Please share them with us in celebration of all the women that make this sector amazing to work in and a force within our communities. If you are looking for ways to pass along your skills and expertise, check out the current volunteer positions at www.govolunteer.ca.

 

Thank you to the amazing women that passed this advice on to me:

Colleen Kelly, former Vantage Point Executive Director
Denise Baker, Vantage Point Executive Director
Martha Sales, Coach and Founder of Achieve Your Mark, Vantage Point Knowledge Philanthropist & Board Member
Tammy Robertson, President, Professional Coach and Author, Work Heart Consulting
Hildy Gottlieb, Co-Founder, Creating the Future

Author

Maria Turnbull

Maria Turnbull brings over 20 years of leadership experience in staff and director roles within the not-for-profit sector, both here in Canada and in the UK. With a BA in International Relations and MBA, Maria is a skilled facilitator and consultant in board governance, organizational development,...

Related Posts

PayPal Webinar

From Overwhelmed to Action: Diversify Your Charity’s Revenue Mix with No-Cost Digital Giving Tools

Join Vantage Point and PayPal Giving Fund for this practical webinar to explore how giving is changing in Canada and what it means for your organization. Through current sector data, real-world examples, and practical strategies, you’ll discover no-cost digital giving tools and community-led fundraising approaches that can help diversify your revenue and create new opportunities for donor engagement.

Beyond Oversight and Towards Impact: Values Based Governance

An Evaluation of Executive Lab: The Impact of Our Leadership Training

An Evaluation of Executive Lab: The Impact of Our Leadership Training

Planning: Strategy & Workforce

by Vantage Point | Feb 5, 2018

A not-for-profit organization’s effectiveness and capacity to navigate change depends largely on its people. Ask anyone about the characteristics of strong and effective not-for-profit organizations and the conversation will inevitably turn to leadership.

Vantage Point’s work is in building the skills and knowledge of not-for-profit leaders to strengthen their leadership performance and impact. In 2017, we did an in-depth evaluation of our program Executive Lab, an advanced program for senior leaders. The impact on individuals and organizations is remarkable.

Vantage Point’s Executive Lab program was first launched as the Executive Director Learning Circle in 2006. Since then, we have engaged nearly 150 senior not-for-profit leaders in peer-based learning to develop personal leadership competencies and improve organizational performance.

Through online survey responses and participant interviews, past Executive Lab participants confirmed that the program directly impacted their leadership abilities in several ways:

  • 82% of participants agreed that because of Executive Lab, their effectiveness as a leader, confidence, and competence with their executive role and responsibility greatly improved
  • 73% said their relationship with their board has improved
  • 68% significantly increased the number of donors and volunteers committed to their cause
  • 100% said the scope of programs was much better
  • 75% said their program effectiveness was much better The evaluation included three core themes to determine the specific areas of the program’s impact:

1. Leadership Effectiveness: In terms of their leadership, participants saw the largest increase in their comfort with their executive director role, leadership effectiveness, leadership strengths, and relationship with their board. These elements are all critical to the success of senior not-for-profit leaders.

2. Organizational Effectiveness: Participants reported an increase in their organizational budget, increase in donors, reduction of staff turnover, and increase in their number of volunteers. These measures show an increased capacity in these organizations, as well as a strengthened resiliency.

3. Organizational Change: Participants saw an increase in their scope of programs, staff knowledge, community outreach, and program effectiveness. It is through these types of changes that not-for-profits can better fulfill their missions. We know that one of the challenges in supporting capacity building is that the impact doesn’t happen overnight. The impact of our work is long term, and not always easy to articulate. These results are truly remarkable and overwhelmingly point to the fact that leadership training is crucial in the success and sustainability of not-for-profit organizations.

At Vantage Point we are fully committed to lifting leadership in the sector.

Join us for Executive Lab 2018

Our next cohort of Executive Lab begins on March 7, 2018. Applications are due February 14, 2018. Apply today!

Related Posts

PayPal Webinar

From Overwhelmed to Action: Diversify Your Charity’s Revenue Mix with No-Cost Digital Giving Tools

Join Vantage Point and PayPal Giving Fund for this practical webinar to explore how giving is changing in Canada and what it means for your organization. Through current sector data, real-world examples, and practical strategies, you’ll discover no-cost digital giving tools and community-led fundraising approaches that can help diversify your revenue and create new opportunities for donor engagement.